Panera and Crumbl face customer backlash over declining quality and rising prices

In recent months, diners across the United Kingdom and the United States have taken to review sites, social media and online forums to voice frustration with two of the most popular bakery‑style chains. Panera Bread, long celebrated for its “homestyle” soups and breads, and Crumbl Cookies, the Utah‑based brand that exploded on Instagram with its ever‑changing flavour list, both report growing complaints about the taste, portion size and cost of their signature items.

Both chains have expanded rapidly in the past decade, opening thousands of outlets and adopting a model that relies on large commissary kitchens and pre‑frozen products. The shift from on‑site baking to bulk production has, according to customers, eroded the freshness that once defined the brands. In a review of the Flatiron Panera Bread in New York City, a Google user wrote:

Media additions

"I'm not sure if it's just this location, but the bread tastes like store shelf bread, not fresh baked bread."

Panera’s own leadership has acknowledged that the expansion has forced cost‑cutting decisions. In a Business Insider interview, CEO Paul Carbone admitted regret over moves such as downsizing portions and swapping out premium ingredients. Those choices, the interview notes, are among the most common complaints from the brand’s long‑time patrons.

Meanwhile, Crumbl Cookies has grown from 55 stores in 2019 to over 1,000 in 2024, a pace that has stretched the brand’s supply chain. The weekly rotation of new flavours, once a marketing triumph, now comes with a reputation for inconsistency. Reddit threads reveal a growing sentiment that the cookies are “over‑rated” and that the brand’s “justifiably popular” status has slipped. One user wrote, “Worst part is it tastes way worse now.” Comments also point to “shrinkflation,” with the cookies reportedly shrinking by around 30 % while prices rise. “INSANE for them to make us guess what size cookie we'll get. Wild to cut the size by like 30% and expect people to be just good with it?” one Redditor said.

Panera and Crumbl are not alone. The same trend appears across other bakery chains. Paris Baguette, with its self‑service model and French‑Korean aesthetic, has seen a sharp drop in quality and a jump in prices. A Reddit user noted that the quality had “noticeably declined,” while a Yelp reviewer complained that a blueberry muffin had risen from $3.99 to $5.43. The chain has also faced legal scrutiny, including a $3 million payment for labour violations in New York City in 2023.

London‑based Pret a Manger, which prides itself on fresh, ready‑to‑eat sandwiches, has seen a spike in prices that has irked loyal customers. A Reddit user remarked that while the food quality was “better,” the price increase made it hard to justify the premium. Pret’s rapid expansion has also led to a higher number of outlets in the London metropolitan area, with nearly 300 stores as of October 2026.

Lady M, the boutique cake chain, has maintained its luxury positioning but has also faced criticism over shrinking portions and higher prices. A Yelp reviewer described the cake texture as “factory‑made,” and another noted that the slice size had shrunk, comparing it to past years. The brand’s expansion to 25 locations across the country has not stopped the perception that the value proposition is slipping.

Cinnabon, with its global presence, has received similar feedback. Redditors have complained that the cinnamon buns are now “stale and hard to eat” and that the price of a $7 roll feels steep. The brand’s once‑iconic “ooey‑gooey” texture has been described as “not even close to what it was in the late 80s.” These remarks mirror the broader pattern of consumers feeling that the classic experience has been diluted by scale.

Across all these chains, the core issue is the same: the need to balance rapid franchising and logistical efficiency with the quality and price expectations that built their brand reputation. Customers are increasingly aware of the trade‑offs that come with large‑scale operations, particularly when they involve frozen or pre‑prepared products. The backlash has highlighted a shift in consumer priorities, with many willing to pay a premium for authenticity and freshness, but unwilling to accept a perceived drop in value.

For Panera Bread, the challenge will be to address the perception that its bread and soups are no longer freshly baked. The company’s acknowledgment of past cost‑cutting moves suggests that it is aware of the problem, but concrete steps to reverse the trend are not yet public. Crumbl Cookies, meanwhile, will need to reconcile its marketing promise of novelty with the need for consistent quality across its rapidly expanding network. The “shrinkflation” comments indicate that price hikes are not meeting consumer expectations for proportionate value.

Other chains that have faced similar criticism are also under pressure. Paris Baguette’s recent labour settlement and rising muffin prices, Pret a Manger’s price jump, Lady M’s shrinking slices and Cinnabon’s stale buns all point to a wider industry challenge: maintaining the artisanal feel that customers love while scaling to meet demand. The backlash across these brands could prompt a reevaluation of sourcing, production methods and pricing strategies.

While the sources do not detail immediate corporate responses, the public outcry is likely to influence future decisions. Customers are increasingly vocal on platforms such as Reddit, Yelp and Google Reviews, and their collective voice can drive change in how these chains balance growth with quality. The next few months may see adjustments to ingredient sourcing, new menu offerings or revised pricing structures as the brands respond to the growing demand for authenticity and value.