Dutch court bans BYD from selling Defender copycat Ti7 in EU
A Dutch court issued a preliminary injunction banning BYD from selling its Ti7 SUV across the EU after ruling it infringes JLR's Defender design rights.
A Dutch court banned BYD from selling its Ti7 SUV across the European Union after ruling that the Chinese automaker infringed Jaguar Land Rover's registered design rights for the Defender. According to the District Court of The Hague, the preliminary injunction was issued on November 20, 2026, marking a legal victory for parent company Tata Motors. The preliminary relief judge determined that the seven-seat Ti7 copies characteristic and distinctive elements of the Defender. Key points of comparison noted by the court included the flat-roof silhouette, boxy appearance, upright proportions, tailgate styling, squared-off wheel arches, rounded corners and shoulders, continuous glasshouse, and the solid panel behind the rear passenger door. BYD's lawyers argued that the two vehicles differed in their headlights, grille, bumper layout, hood, and windows, but the court concluded those details were insufficient to change the overall impression.
The restriction goes into effect one week after the ruling, applying across all 27 member states of the European Union. Beyond banning imports, sales, and advertising, the court also barred BYD from producing the vehicle at its upcoming plant in Szeged, Hungary, which is slated to begin mass production early next year. If BYD violates the EU ban, it faces daily fines or penalties per vehicle, capped at 10 million euros. The Ti7 is not currently on sale in the EU, and BYD stated it has no concrete plans to place the vehicle on the market there. The court issued the ban partly because the Chinese automaker would not commit to staying out of the European market.
Media additions
The Dutch court ruled that it does not have jurisdiction over BYD’s affiliate in the United Kingdom. Customer deliveries in the UK are planned to start in January 2027 and remain unaffected by the decision. JLR originally initiated the lawsuit after BYD listed the Ti7 for order on its UK website. The UK version of the Ti7 undercuts the Defender in price. JLR sells thousands of Defenders to retail customers, making it a popular model for the company.
Legal Context and Precedent
| Legal Action / Case | Year | Court / Jurisdiction | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Landwind X7 vs. Range Rover Evoque | 2019 | Beijing Court, China | JLR won after court found Jiangling copied five exterior features, halting sales and ordering damages. |
| INEOS Grenadier vs. Classic Defender | 2020 | UK High Court / UK IPO | JLR failed to register classic Defender shape as a 3D trademark, clearing INEOS. |
| BYD Ti7 vs. Land Rover Defender | 2026 | District Court of The Hague, Netherlands | Preliminary injunction issued banning Ti7 sales and production across the EU. |
Earlier in the legal dispute, court-appointed bailiffs acting for JLR seized digital files from BYD’s European offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp, Netherlands. BYD argued that the seizure was a fishing expedition that swept up unrelated data. Subsequently, the District Court of The Hague ordered Jaguar Land Rover to destroy or return documents and digital records seized during the raid, with non-compliance carrying hourly penalties.
BYD stated that it strongly disagrees with the decision, maintaining that the Ti7 SUV is the result of independent design work and confirming it will appeal the ruling. JLR noted that legal proceedings remain ongoing. The preliminary ruling is not necessarily the final word in the dispute.
What to Watch Next
- Customer deliveries of the Ti7 in the United Kingdom remain on track to begin in January 2027, while JLR is expected to weigh filing a separate UK design-infringement lawsuit in British courts before those deliveries begin.
- JLR must initiate substantive proceedings within six months of the November 20, 2026 judgment, or the preliminary injunction will lapse.
Explore more corporate developments in our dedicated Business coverage.