UK government introduces bill to ban new leasehold flats and cap ground rent
The government has published a draft bill to ban new leasehold flats and cap ground rents at £250 as part of reforms to the tenure system.
The government has published a draft bill to ban new leasehold flats and cap ground rents at £250, marking the most ambitious attempt yet to dismantle a tenure system ministers describe as feudal.
The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, unveiled on Tuesday 27 January, would make commonhold — where flat owners collectively own and manage their building — the default for new developments in England and Wales. Existing ground rents above £250 would be treated as prohibited, falling to a peppercorn after 40 years. Forfeiture, the power that lets freeholders seize a home over debts as low as £350, would be abolished.
Media additions
What the bill contains
The draft legislation tackles three interlocking problems. First, it ends the sale of new leasehold flats "except in limited cases", replacing them with a revitalised commonhold model already standard in Australia, Canada, the US and much of Europe. Second, it caps ground rent on existing leases at £250 a year, with a statutory sunset to peppercorn after four decades. Third, it strips freeholders of forfeiture rights, substituting a court-led enforcement regime with cost safeguards.
Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, told the BBC the current system was "blighting lives" and an "anachronism in the twenty-first century". The Prime Minister, in a video posted to TikTok the same morning, framed the cap as a cost-of-living measure: "Good news for homeowners, we're capping ground rent at £250. That means if you are a leaseholder, and your ground rent is more than £250, you'll be paying less."
| Measure | Current position | Proposed change |
|---|---|---|
| New leasehold flats | Permitted | Banned; commonhold becomes default |
| Ground rent on existing leases | Uncapped; can double or rise with inflation | Capped at £250, then peppercorn after 40 years |
| Forfeiture threshold | £350 service charge debt | Abolished; replaced by court-led process |
| Commonhold conversion | Possible but rarely used | New streamlined process; majority agreement required |
Scale of the problem
There are around five million leasehold properties in England and Wales, 70 per cent of them flats. The government estimates 3.8 million still attract ground rent, with homeowners collectively paying more than £600m in 2025. The English Housing Survey put the average annual ground rent in 2023/24 at £304, already above the proposed cap.
Fozia Malik, a leaseholder in Oldham, told the BBC her ground rent is due to rise from £150 to £300 in January, on top of service charges exceeding £4,000 a year. "I would never buy a leasehold flat again," she said, describing it as a "continuous torture cell". Her managing agent attributes the charges to fire-safety insurance costs outside its control.
Freeholder pushback and the Treasury row
The Residential Freehold Association, representing the UK's largest freeholders, claims £18.7bn "could be wiped out from investments overnight". It argues the cap is a "wholly unjustified interference with existing property rights" and warns professional freeholders will exit the sector, "hindering building safety projects and disrupting the day-to-day lives of residents".
Legal battlefield
The freeholders' primary weapon is Article 1 of Protocol 1 (A1P1) of the European Convention on Human Rights, protecting peaceful enjoyment of possessions. They argue the cap expropriates contractual income without compensation. The government's defence rests on proportionality: the measure modernises an outdated tenure, aligns existing leases with post-2022 ones (where ground rent was already banned on new builds), and preserves compensation for 40 years via the £250 formula.
A similar defence succeeded in October 2025, when the Divisional Court rejected a challenge to the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024, specifically the abolition of marriage value on lease extensions. Freeholders are appealing. Sebastian O'Kelly of the Leasehold Knowledge Partnership notes the Scottish precedent: feuduties (Scotland's equivalent of ground rent) were phased out over 32 years with compensation linked to 2.5% Consolidated Loan Stock, avoiding A1P1 challenges.
The Leasehold Knowledge Partnership also flags a potential loophole: freeholders could create headleases carrying disguised ground rents, "estate service charge linked to RPI", passed down as service charges. The draft bill bans administration fees on prohibited rents, but the Partnership warns the back-door risk remains for new buildings.
Existing leaseholders: the conversion gap
While the bill streamlines conversion to commonhold, requiring majority agreement among residents, the mechanics remain unresolved. Giles Grover of End Our Cladding Scandal warns of a "two-tier system": new buyers get commonhold; millions of current leaseholders stay trapped. "It's so complicated, will the measures that are being introduced actually benefit everyone?" he asked the BBC.
The 2024 Act, which granted 990-year lease extensions at peppercorn and removed marriage value, is still not in force, stalled by the judicial review and, the government says, drafting errors needing correction. The new bill does not clarify whether it will fix those errors or require separate legislation. The Leasehold Knowledge Partnership notes "no clear timeline" and suggests the new law may not take practical effect until 2028–29.
What to watch next
- Committee scrutiny: The draft bill goes to the Housing Committee before formal introduction. Expect amendments on the £250 level, the 40-year sunset, and conversion mechanics.
- Judicial review: The RFA has "all but threatened" a challenge. The 2024 Act appeal will be a bellwether.
- Consultations: The government has promised further consultation on the cap value, conversion process, and fleecehold estate charges.
- Commencement: Even after Royal Assent, provisions must be "switched on" by secondary legislation, a process that added years to previous reforms.
- Building safety interplay: Freeholders claim lost ground-rent income will stall cladding remediation. The government counters that leaseholders already bear those costs.
International context
England and Wales are outliers. Commonhold equivalents, strata title, condominium, copropriété, are standard across Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the US and continental Europe. Scotland abolished feudal tenure in 2004 after a 30-year transition. Ireland banned new ground rents in 1978 and introduced Owners Management Corporations for apartment blocks in 2011. The Law Commission deemed commonhold the fairest model; the 2002 Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act created it in England, but fewer than 20 developments adopted it, largely because developers and lenders stuck with leasehold.
For now, the bill is a draft. The political will appears firm, Starmer called it "a promise that we said we'd deliver", but the path from Whitehall paper to leaseholder relief runs through Parliament, the courts, and a sector that has spent decades turning ground rent into an asset class worth billions.