British government complacent on foreign cyber threats, Lords warn
A parliamentary committee has warned that the government's legislative programme is not keeping pace with resilience challenges, while criticizing the limited scope of the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill.
Cyber bill criticised as scope remains limited
The Cyber Security and Resilience Bill has been more than five years in development. The committee wrote that the “government’s legislative programme is not keeping pace with the resilience challenges identified by this inquiry.” While the bill “would provide useful baseline requirements,” its scope is limited, and most of the public sector is not covered. In the Lords last month, peers defeated the government twice — calling for regular reviews of whether the legislation remains fit for purpose, and for a register of foreign powers that pose cybersecurity threats to Britain. The government’s National Cyber Action Plan, intended to defend the wider economy against state-backed and criminal hacking, has also faced delays; sources told The Record it was expected in mid-November. Michael Brunton-Spall, deputy director of cyber services at the Government Cyber Unit, told the committee the government and public sector face “critically high cyber and digital resilience risks” and “extremely low levels of resilience.” Paddy McGuinness, a former deputy national security adviser, was asked whether the government’s plans matched the threat. “The answer to your core question about whether it is adequate to the severity of the cyber threat is no,” he said.Supply chain vulnerabilities shock peers
The committee said it was “shocked” by the UK’s exposure on medicines. The country imports 80 per cent of the active ingredient in penicillin from China, and the last domestic antibiotic plant closed in 2025. Only one antibiotic manufacturer remains in Europe. The Department of Health mandates an eight-week buffer stock for certain medicines, but peers said ministers should assess whether this provides “sufficient coverage” of products critical to national resilience during prolonged disruption. Food supply is similarly concentrated. Just nine retailers account for around 94.5 per cent of food sold through UK supermarkets, using 131 distribution hubs. Only two or three days’ stock is held for some commodities. Baroness Jean Coussins, the crossbench chair of the committee, said: “A cyber attack can quickly morph into a power cut, then a shutdown of transport, then empty food shelves in the shops.”| Metric | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Annual attempted cyber-attacks on UK defence systems | More than 90,000 | Herald Scotland |
| Annual cost of recovering from cyber-attacks | £14.7 billion | Herald Scotland |
| Penicillin active ingredient imported from China | 80% | Multiple sources |
| UK food market share held by nine retailers | 94.5% | Herald Scotland |
| Critical national infrastructure owned by private sector | 80% | iNews |
Command structure and devolved cooperation
Peers urged the government to adopt a Scottish-style regional command structure for national emergencies. In Scotland, Regional and Local Resilience Partnerships bring together police, fire, health boards and councils. In England, planning sits with Local Resilience Forums, but the committee found “no clear link between those forums and national decision-making.” The government “seemed deficient in a clear command and control mechanism for translating top-down decision-making into lower-level delivery uniformly across the country,” the report said. The committee recommended strengthening command and control between national (gold command) and local (bronze command) structures, developing middle-level (silver command) management of the kind that exists in Scotland, and establishing regional co-ordination centres across the UK using existing structures where possible. It also said the UK Government had failed to bring devolved administrations into emergency planning early enough or consistently enough.Whole-of-society recommendations
The report’s recommendations span recruitment, infrastructure, education and governance:- Expand the armed forces “gap year” scheme to include NEETs — 16 to 24-year-olds not in employment, education or training, to generate surge capacity for major conflict.
- Scrap plans to switch off Digital Terrestrial Television from the mid-2030s, warning this “risks weakening national resilience by reducing universal access to communication.”
- Introduce a statutory duty on public and private sector organisations to conduct routine stress-testing exercises.
- Require water companies to demonstrate they can maintain emergency supplies and distribution during prolonged outages.
- Teach resilience skills, first aid, CPR, survival skills, household emergency planning, climate and flood risk, digital safety and information literacy, in schools, further education and workplaces.
- Appoint a Cabinet minister with sole responsibility for resilience within six months, supported by a Chief Resilience Officer at permanent secretary level.
- Create a national register of volunteers and civil reservists, and introduce paid “civic resilience leave” so workers can train and volunteer without losing income.
- Establish a strategic reserve of critical food and agricultural inputs, including fertiliser.
- Invest in domestic production capacity for essential medicines and pharmaceutical ingredients.
- Require the Prime Minister to make an annual statement to Parliament on the state of UK preparedness.
Public communication and the ‘Be Ready’ campaign
The committee acknowledged the government’s “Be Ready” campaign, launched last month, which urges households to stockpile enough bottled water and essential items for three days. But it criticised the reliance on a website for public advice instead of sending every household a booklet, as Sweden and Denmark do. “Evidence suggests that the public would reward honesty and openness with trust and reassurance, not fear and alarm,” the report concluded. Baroness Coussins added: “People are more than willing to step up in an emergency but less clear why and how.”Government response
A Cabinet Office spokesperson said: “We thank the Committee for their report, which we will carefully review. It highlights the need for action across government and society to boost our collective resilience – closely involving local, regional and national bodies. That is exactly what this government is doing.” The spokesperson cited the “Be Ready” campaign, the largest home defence exercise in recent history planned for next year, and investment of over £1 billion in pandemic security, adding: “Our work on resilience goes further than successive governments have ever gone before. However, we know there is still more work to do to make the UK the most resilient country we can be, including working with and learning from our allies.” The Security Minister discussed resilience with allies aboard HMS Prince of Wales in Oslo last week.What to watch next
- Cyber Security and Resilience Bill vote, expected in the Commons within eight days of the report’s publication (Monday 16 November 2026).
- National Cyber Action Plan, delayed publication expected mid-November.
- Government response to committee recommendations, including whether a dedicated resilience minister will be appointed within the six-month timeframe urged by peers.
- Largest home defence exercise, scheduled for 2027.
- Devolved administration engagement, whether the UK Government brings Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish bodies into emergency planning earlier and more consistently.
Media additions