Saturday, 21 November 2026 Newsarchy UK live index
NewsarchyUKUK
Every UK story. Mapped, sourced, and explained where it matters.
BREAKING
Politics

First Minister 'gobsmacked' by Westminster's refusal to devolve more powers to Wales

Wales First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth expressed shock after Westminster officially rejected the devolution of policing, justice, and rail powers to Wales.

Text:
First Minister 'gobsmacked' by Westminster's refusal to devolve more powers to Wales
First Minister 'gobsmacked' by Westminster's refusal to devolve more powers to Wales

Wales First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth has declared he is gobsmacked after Prime Minister Andy Burnham rejected calls to devolve key powers to Wales. The political clash erupted following a formal letter sent to Cardiff Bay, in which the prime minister ruled out the transfer of responsibilities over policing and justice, the Crown Estate, and rail infrastructure. According to reporting from the BBC, the prime minister stated he was not persuaded by the case for devolution in those areas, arguing that integrated cross-border systems remain vital for public protection and resource sharing.

That letter abruptly ended optimism generated following a meeting between the two leaders in Glasgow. The first minister had previously expressed belief that the prime minister was instinctively inclined toward devolution. Instead, the final decision drew fierce condemnation, with ap Iorwerth accusing the prime minister of turning his back on devolution and treating English regions with greater respect than Wales. As detailed by Nation, the first minister argued that the decision shows Westminster is disregarding the views of the people of Wales and proving that the prime minister does not view Wales as an equal nation.

Media additions

Image via Wales Online
Image via Wales Online
Image via North Wales Live
Image via North Wales Live
Image via SSBCrack
Image via SSBCrack

The fallout has exposed internal fractures within the Labour Party itself. Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates reiterated support at a party conference for devolving policing and the Crown Estate, placing him directly at odds with Downing Street. Meanwhile, former first minister Mark Drakeford voiced disappointment over the decision, suggesting in BBC coverage that the prime minister fails to fully understand how different things are when talking about a country operating alongside the Senedd. Drakeford indicated that internal discussions within the party would continue.

Defending the decision, Welsh Secretary Stephen Kinnock argued that transferring the requested powers would lead to destabilisation, fragmentation, and disintegration. As reported by Wales Online, Kinnock instead pointed to an alternative offer centred on fiscal flexibility, employment support, reindustrialisation, innovation, and regional empowerment designed to work alongside local authorities. The prime minister's letter also noted that UK government officials are working with the Welsh government to further understand a proposal to pilot a child payment.

Area of Request Prime Minister's Stance Offered Alternative / Rationale
Policing & Justice Rejected Maintain integrated England and Wales framework for interoperability, cross-border capabilities, and a shared justice system.
Crown Estate Rejected Current model provides best economic and social benefits via scale, financial capacity, and a diversified portfolio.
Rail Infrastructure Rejected Funding and delivery handled by Great British Railways in collaboration with Transport for Wales and the Welsh government.
Fiscal & Employment Powers Partially Accepted Policy sprints and devolution of employment support through regional frameworks and local authority partners.

Reaction from opposition parties and external organisations was swift. As detailed by Nation.Cymru, Welsh Liberal Democrat leader David Chadwick questioned why Labour refuses to treat Wales as an equal nation to Scotland, noting that the prime minister spent years telling Westminster to trust Manchester with more power. Welsh Conservative leader Darren Millar dismissed the debate as an unnecessary distraction from core issues like NHS waiting lists, educational attainment, the cost of living, and economic growth.

Campaign group YesCymru also condemned the refusal. Chair Rob Hughes argued that Wales is treated like a child rather than an equal partner, noting that every single council in Wales, the Senedd, and Welsh Labour itself wanted the Crown Estate devolved.

As the constitutional row continues, the prime minister's officials will engage with a commission set up by Plaid Cymru to look at future options, including independence. Both administrations face ongoing debates over regional governance, economic growth, and the extent of devolved authority as political pressure mounts across Cardiff and Westminster.

Related stories