Saturday, 21 November 2026 Newsarchy UK live index
NewsarchyUKUK
Every UK story. Mapped, sourced, and explained where it matters.
BREAKING
Politics

Andy Burnham rules out transfer of further policing and rail powers to Wales

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has rejected calls from Welsh First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth to devolve policing, justice, Crown Estate, and rail powers to Wales.

Text:
Andy Burnham rules out transfer of further policing and rail powers to Wales
Andy Burnham rules out transfer of further policing and rail powers to Wales

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has ruled out the transfer of further policing, justice, Crown Estate, and rail powers to Wales, prompting sharp accusations from political opponents that his government is resisting devolution outside of English regions. The decision was communicated via a five-page letter sent on Friday, 20 November 2026, to Welsh First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth.

In the correspondence, Mr Burnham stated that his administration was not persuaded by calls to devolve responsibilities currently managed at the UK level. This stance drew immediate criticism from Mr ap Iorwerth, who told reporters he was pretty gobsmacked by Westminster’s refusal. According to BBC Radio 4's Today programme and reports from Yahoo News, the First Minister argued that the Prime Minister showed greater respect for English regions and noted that Mr Burnham had wielded more influence over policing as mayor of Greater Manchester than the current Welsh leader possesses. Mr ap Iorwerth accused Whitehall of fighting against Welsh devolution.

Media additions

Image via thebangoraye.com
Image via thebangoraye.com
Image via Nation.Cymru
Image via Nation.Cymru
Image via Wales Online
Image via Wales Online

The letter addresses specific policy areas individually. On policing and justice, Mr Burnham argued that maintaining an integrated England and Wales system ensures interoperability, cross-border cooperation, and access to specialist capabilities. On the Crown Estate—which includes valuable seabed rights off the Welsh coast—the Prime Minister maintained that the current model maximizes economic and social benefits through scale and specialist expertise, rejecting demands for management to be transferred to Wales. Regarding rail infrastructure, Mr Burnham stated that funding and delivery are best handled by Great British Railways in collaboration with Transport for Wales and the Welsh Government. He cautioned against fragmenting a highly integrated cross-border network, although he acknowledged historic underfunding and pointed to a pipeline of rail projects valued at up to £14 billion. Additional economic investments highlighted in the letter include nuclear power development at Wylfa and steel production support at Port Talbot, alongside commitments to fiscal flexibility and employment support.

Reactions across the political spectrum highlighted deep divisions over the constitutional settlement. Welsh Secretary Stephen Kinnock defended the Prime Minister’s approach, describing it as a bold offer focused on regional growth and job creation. Conversely, Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates had previously reaffirmed his party’s policy supporting the devolution of policing and the Crown Estate, placing him at odds with the Prime Minister. Other political figures weighed in on the dispute. Welsh Liberal Democrat leader David Chadwick questioned why Labour refuses to treat Wales as an equal Nation to Scotland, while Welsh Conservative leader Darren Millar dismissed the debate as an unnecessary distraction from the cost of living and NHS waiting lists. YesCymru chair Rob Hughes criticized Westminster's refusal, noting that every council in Wales and the Senedd had backed devolving the Crown Estate.

Key Areas of Disagreement

Policy Area Welsh Government / Senedd Position UK Government Stance (Andy Burnham)
Policing and Justice Sought legislative devolution and a justice system tailored to Wales. Retain integrated England and Wales framework for specialist capabilities and cross-border cooperation.
The Crown Estate Transfer management of seabed and assets to Wales, mirroring Scotland. Retain current model to leverage scale, financial capacity, and long-term investment expertise.
Rail Infrastructure Devolve full responsibility for rail infrastructure and planning. Keep centralized through Great British Railways to avoid fragmenting the cross-border network.

Looking ahead, discussions between the UK and Welsh governments are set to continue. Mr Burnham proposed further work on employment support, justice arrangements, policing governance, and fiscal flexibility, alongside continued cooperation on economic investment.

Related stories